Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York May 12, 1933 (Witkin v. Charles D. Beckwith, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-05-1933

lead-opinion

Sherman, J.

The judgment here is in negligence and rests upon a jury’s verdict awarding plaintiff a considerable sum in damages. Two prior trials resulted in disagreements. We are now asked to direct a fourth trial. Plaintiff’s witnesses, so it is claimed, have testified to details contradictory of earlier versions. Plaintiff himself did not testify. These circumstances, it is said, taint the verdict, demonstrate that the believable evidence points to a conclusion favorable to defendants and require a new trial. That a question of fact exists which must be resolved by a jury is conceded.

*329Defendants do not dispute the serious injuries to plaintiff, which affected his mind and speech mechanism through brain hemorrhages and paralyzed him in several respects, apparently constituting a valid reason for the failure to call him as a witness. In any event, such failure of the plaintiff to take the witness chair might be a proper subject of comment to the jury; it does not, however, supply any basis for the reversal of the verdict by this court, when the facts of the accident are described by other eye-witnesses.

About dusk, while plaintiff was walking across the plaza made by the intersection of three streets, Southern boulevard, Prospect avenue and East One Hundred and Forty-ninth street, in the Bronx, he claims to have been struck by appellants’ automobile. Two lines of street car tracks unite where East One Hundred and Forty-ninth street runs into Southern boulevard. Plaintiff, an elderly man, was crossing from the southwest comer of One Hundred and Forty-ninth street and Southern boulevard to the southeast corner; his course was no other than the customary one pursued by pedestrians and it involved his traversing the plaza for a distance of about seventy-five feet from the sidewalk to the place where he was injured. There is ample evidence that the traffic lights were in his favor when he set out to walk across that space.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.