Court of Appeals of Georgia January 21, 1933, 22208 (Capps v. Toccoa Falls Light & Power Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-01-1933

Jenkins, P. J.

'(After stating the foregoing facts.)

The first headnote requires no elaboration. The previous litigation was a mere personal action by the claimant against certain defendants, among whom was the plaintiff in fi. fa., and sought merely a personal judgment against the defendants named. Accordingly, it did not pertain to the same cause of action as that involved in the instant claim case, under the rules set forth by the first headnote. Not being the same cause of action, the plaintiff in fi. fa. could not be bound under the doctrine of res judicata.

*273An estoppel by judgment, however, can arise by virtue of a judgment authorized by the pleadings, rendered in previous litigation between the same parties, based upon an altogether different cause of ■ action. The question presented, therefore, is whether the decree taken in the former litigation, actually adjudicating a question not raised by the pleadings, but entered by the consent of all parties, is conclusive upon the plaintiff in fi. fa. We think that such a decree thus formally entered by consent is binding, according to its terms, upon the parties agreeing thereto; but in the instant case all that the decree sought to do was to determine the title to the property described as “the Capps Cotton Mill or Capps Manufacturing Company property,” and did not purport to adjudicate or determine what constituted the property referred to. The pleadings not having raised such latter question so as to render such an adjudication necessary, and the consent judgment itself not having sought in any wise to determine the question now in dispute, the plaintiff in fi. fa. is not bound under the doctrine of estoppel by judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.