New York Surrogate's Court June 28, 1933 (In re the Estate of Valverde)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-06-1933
Wingate, S.
The logical effect of the main argument of counsel for the movant herein would result in a thesis which neither he nor any other competent attorney would care to postulate. It is in substance that since section 101, subdivision 3, of the Insurance Law gives to the insurer the sole option to make the application for the policy a part of the contract, such application, if the option be exercised, should not be considered by the court in an interpretation of the contract of insurance. While Becker v. Colonial Life Ins. Co. (153 App. Div. 382) and Archer v. Equitable Life Assur. Soc. (169 id. 43; affd., 218 N. Y. 19, 22) give some of the reasons underlying this enactment in question, the effect of the exercise of such option is stated in the enactment itself and in the opinion of the Court of Appeals in the Archer case (see pages 22, 23), and is that by such incorporation the application becomes an integral part of the contract between the parties.
It is primary that in the interpretation of any written document every portion thereof is to be given effect, and it is beyond the power of the court in the ordinary case to delete or disregard any part. (Fleischman v. Furgueson, 223 N. Y. 235, 239; Adams v. Massey, 184 id. 62, 69; Matter of Reppucci,145 Misc. 671, 677.) In every *348contract provisions thereof are inserted at the election of one or the other party. To maintain that any parts so included on the insistence of one, should, in the absence of inequitable conduct on his part, be disregarded in arriving at the meaning of the agreement as a whole, is a redudio ad absurdum which would destroy all contract law. It must follow, therefore, that by reason of its physical incorporation therein, the application becomes an integral part of the contract for better or for worse, and that its language must be considered by the court in the interpretation of the document.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit