Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit May 29, 1933, No. 5640 (Demeter v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-05-1933

HITZ, Associate Justice.

This appellant is a soldier discharged from the United States Army for disability incurred in the line of duty.

At the time of his discharge he had in force a policy of war risk insurance) entitling him to $16,000 in certain installment payments upon certain conditions.

In the course of pleading the plaintiff finally joined issue upon the defendant’s third plea to the amended declaration, which denied that the plaintiff “became permanently and totally disabled on April 23, 1918, or at any time while said contract of insurance was in force.”

His disability was caused by a falling timber in an unloading operation, which was so thrown or dropped from a truck as to strike him in the baek while at work on the ground.

This occurred at Brownsville, Tex., on March 29,1917, and on April 23,1918, he was discharged from the army, for disability incurred in the line of duty rendering him unfit to perform the duties of a soldier.

*189The contract of insurance expired on May 31, 1918, so that the issue here presented is whether before that time plaintiff was totally and permanently disabled from following continuously any substantially gainful occupation within the meaning of the war risk insurance acts.

This issue the jury found against him, and from the judgment of the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia, based on their verdict, we have this appeal, with 13 assignments of error, 9 of which deal with rulings on the evidence, and 4 relate to prayers granted or denied.

Except for 3 depositions, the basis for assignment No. 7, all of the evidence upon which errors are assigned was documentary, from the files of the Veterans’ Bureau, and, in accordance with D. C. Supreme Court rule 76, was summarized by the court’s commissioner of veterans’ affairs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.