Supreme Court of North Carolina October 31, 1934 (Guy v. Ætna Life Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-10-1934
Stacy, C. J.
This is the same case that was before us at the last term, opinion filed 28 February, 1934, and reported in 206 N. C., 118, 172 S. E., 885.
Ample evidence of plaintiff’s permanent total disability was adduced on the hearing, but it was thought the letter offered by the plaintiff shows that no proof thereof had been furnished the company as provided by the policy. The action, therefore, was dismissed as in case of non-suit.
Wyche v. Ins. Co., ante,
45. In this we think his Honor overlooked the denial of liability contained in said letter, which dispensed with the necessity of further proof.
Misskelley v. Ins. Co.,
205 N. C., 496, 171 S. E., 862;
Gerringer v. Ins. Co.,
133 N. C., 407, 45 S. E., 773.
It is established by the decisions in this jurisdiction that a provision in an insurance policy requiring proof of loss, disability or death is waived by the company’s denial of liability, or refusal to pay, upon grounds other than failure to furnish such proof.
Misskelley v. Ins. Co., supra.
The physician’s statement, which the defendant alone interpreted as being adverse to plaintiff’s claim, and which is not in evidence, was not conclusive of the plaintiff’s right to recover.
Fields v. Assurance Co.,
195 N. C., 262, 141 S. E., 743.
Eeversed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit