Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York June 21, 1934 (Cardoner v. St. George Paving Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-06-1934

Martin, J.

The judgment appealed from was obtained by the plaintiff against the defendant, St. George Paving Corporation, upon the theory that the plaintiff was injured because of the negligence of that defendant.

On April 21, 1927, the defendant, appellant, was awarded a contract by the city of New York for the “ Repaving with granite blocks on a concrete foundation the roadway of Brook Avenue from E. 132nd Street to E. 137th Street and from E. 139th Street *453to Westchester Avenue, and setting curb where necessary together with all work incidental thereto.” Work under that contract began during the early part of June, 1927, and while it was in progress on July 1, 1927, the infant plaintiff was injured. This action was then brought to recover damages and a judgment was entered upon the verdict of a jury for the sum of $10,000 and this appeal has been taken therefrom.

The complaint here is undoubtedly based on the theory of negligence. After alleging that the defendant, appellant, and another defendant were engaged in paving work and had piled materials on the public highway it sets forth:

“ Sixth. * * * that defendants were bound to anticipate that such materials would be attractive to the children playing upon the streets and it became their duty to pile the same with reasonable care, so as not to be hable to fall from the play of children thereon and thereabouts. * * *

“ Eighth. That the infant plaintiff, then a child of ten years of age, on the 1st day of July, 1927, played upon the said street and went upon the said pile of materials. That the same thereupon collapsed solely through the aforesaid negligence of the defendants in not piling it with reasonable care and said infant plaintiff was thrown and injured as hereinafter more particularly described.”

The infant plaintiff was seventeen years old at the time of the trial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.