Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit April 11, 1934, No. 9690 (United States v. Kiles)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-04-1934
GARDNER, Circuit Judge.
This is an action brought to recover on a contract of war risk insurance. Right of recovery is asserted on the ground that the *881assured became permanently totally disabled November 1, 1928, during tbe life of tbe policy, and not on tbe ground that the insured died during the life of the policy. Insured died of pneumonia August 17, 1929. It is alleged that insured’s total permanent disability resulted from “extreme nervousness, insanity, organic and functional nervous diseases, arthritis, and general debility.” The answer is in the nature of a general denial.
At the close of all the testimony the government moved for a directed verdict on the grounds that “as a matter of law the plaintiff has not proved * ° insurance contract in force on the date alleged in the petition as amended, November 1, 1928, and * * as a matter of law, he has not proved a prima facie case of permanent total disability on that date.” This motion was denied and the ease was sent to the jury, resulting in a verdict in favor of plaintiff, and from the judgment entered thereon this appeal has been perfected.
It is here contended that (1) there was no substantial evidence that the insurance was in force November 1, 1928; (2) there was no evidence of a valid disagreement between the United States veterans’ bureau and the insured, or the person claiming under the contract of insurance; and (3) there was no substantial evidence of total permanent disability on November 1, 1928, or any other time while the contract of insurance was in effect.
It was conceded on the trial that thei insurance premiums had been paid until May, 1927. On June 27, 1927, the insured converted his war risk insurance into a government life insurance policy, the amount of the policy being reduced from $10,000 to $5,000. Appellant urges that certain receipts or other similar evidence or records of payment that plaintiff introduced were ambiguous.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit