Supreme Court of Colorado February 25, 1935, No. 13,305. (Jones v. Milliken)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-02-1935

Mr. Chibe Justice Butler

delivered the opinion of the court.

Carl S. Milliken, trustee of the Denver police department relief fund, sued Minerva Elizabeth J ones and Myra Stevens Jones, both of whom claimed to be the widow of James C. Jones, a former policeman, to determine which of them is the lawful widow and as such entitled to receive a pension. The trial court, sitting without a jury, held in favor of Myra and Minerva seeks a reversal of the judgment.

Jones and Myra were married in 1881. Two children, both girls, were born to them. In 1891, while J ones was a member of the Denver police department, he killed a man named Strawn, who, Jones claimed, was Myra’s paramour. Jones was charged with murder. While out on bail he lived with Myra in Denver. He was convicted of murder of the second degree, but the sentence was reversed in 1896.

J ones v.

People, 23 Colo. 276, 47 Pac. 275. In 1897 Jones went to Wichita, Kansas, where he resumed marital relations with Myra who, with the children, had gone there to live. Those relations continued until 1901, when Jones came alone to Colorado. In May, 1902, he and Minerva went through a marriage ceremony. Thereafter for twenty-nine years and until his death, which occurred in 1931, they lived together as husband and wife.

The law presumes innocence, not guilt; morality, not immorality; marriage, not concubinage. It follows that there is a presumption that a second marriage is valid and that all obstacles thereto, if any, had been removed. That presumption is not overcome by a pre

*281

sumption that a former marriag'e, once shown to exist, continues. The presumption in favor of a second marriage is not conclusive. However, one attacking such marriage has the burden of proving its invalidity.

In

Pittinger v. Pittinger,

28 Colo. 308, 64 Pac. 195, we said: “In cases of this character, no inflexible rule can be laid down, which would be an infallible test by which to determine whether a marriage has been dissolved or not.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.