Supreme Court of Florida January 24, 1935 (General Motors Acceptance Corp. v. Lynch Building Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-01-1935

Terrell, J.

The appellee, Lynch Building Corporation, exhibited its bill of complaint in the Circuit Court of Duval County praying specific performance of an oral agreement to make a lease. The appellant who was defendant below, moved to dismiss the bill and for better particulars. Both motions were overruled and the cause comes here on appeal from s'aid orders, though the appeal from the order overruling the motion for better particulars is abandoned in this Court.

The appellant urges that the bill of complaint is defective in that the allegations of agency are insufficient, that it fails to show the offer to make and the acceptance of an oral lease, that it does not show Such past performance as to take it out of the Statute of Frauds, and that no constructive fraud being shown equity will not grant specific performance.

The bill in effect alleges that in September, 1929, the plaintiff by written contract leased to the defendant rooms 1316 to 1330 on the thirteenth floor of the Lynch Building in Jacksonville, Florida, for a period of three years, at a rental price of $610.05 per month, and that said space was occupied and used by the defendant according to the terms of said lease until May 15, 1932. It is further alleged that during the month of April, 1932, the defendant approached the agent of the plaintiff and represented to him that it (defendant) expected to concentrate the business of its Tampa and Miami offices' in the Jacksonville office and that it would need additional space for this purpose. In view

*4

of such consolidation it requested that the present lease be cancelled and that it be given a new and additional lease covering rooms 1313 to 1330, thirteenth floor of the Lynch Building, including the corridor space adjacent thereto, the latter lease to run from June 1, 1932, to May 31, 1933, at a yearly rental of $7866.00.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.