Michigan Supreme Court October 31, 1935, Docket No. 62, Calendar No. 38,121. (Dyer v. McQuistion)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-10-1935
lead-opinion
Wiest, J.
I cannot concur in the opinion of Mr. Justice Potter.
In October, 1933, the department approved a settlement agreement between the parties and granted plaintiff’s petition for a lump sum settlement thereunder, stating: “after■ due investigation and consideration of said petition and inquiry into the facts and circumstances of the case.”
*329
In January, 1934, upon plaintiff’s petition for further compensation, the department found that, at the time of the approval of the lump sum settlement, plaintiff was totally disabled and should be permitted to collect compensation for total disability, and the amount paid, by virtue of supplemental agreement and lump sum settlement, should be treated as an advance payment, and awarded him $13.11 per week from December 23, 1933, less the amount paid under the lump sum settlement.
The department assumed power to set aside its former award and adjudicate anew, without any change in the disability of plaintiff and, upon an express finding of no change. We quote the finding:
“And inasmuch as it is not seriously disputed that at the very time the lump sum settlement and supplemental agreement for 89 cents a week were entered into, the plaintiff was totally disabled, there is nothing further for the commission to decide.”
If plaintiff was totally disabled when the department approved the lump sum settlement he was not worse three months later when the department vacated its former order and made the award at bar.
Runnels
v.
Allied Engineers, Inc.,
270 Mich. 153. Without such change the department had no power to review its former order. Weekly payments are subject to review upon change in. degree of, or recovery from disability, but the department cannot otherwise review, reverse, vacate, ignore, repudiate or act anew upon matters once adjudicated.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit