Supreme Court of North Carolina March 20, 1935 (Metropolitan Life Insurance v. Allen)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-03-1935

BeogdeN, J.

A. owns approximately nine thousand acres of land, and agrees to sell to B. a small tract containing about seventy-nine acres. B. enters into possession and makes a part payment on the purchase money, but receives no deed. Thereafter A. executes a deed of trust upon the entire body of land to secure a large indebtedness. About three years after the recording of said deed of trust A. conveys the seventy-nine-acre tract to B. by deed duly recorded. B. mortgages his seventy-nine-acre tract to secure an indebtedness, and being unable to pay, the land is duly sold under the mortgage and purchased by another. By

mesne

conveyances, duly executed and recorded, the title to the land was vested in'the First National Bank of Louisburg, and said bank conveyed the same to* the defendant by deed duly executed and recorded. A., the original owner of the land, did not pay his indebtedness secured by the deed of trust and sale was duly made thereunder, and the whole body of land purchased by the plaintiff. About six years after the land was purchased by the plaintiff it brought a suit in ejectment against the defendant and recovered possession. The defendant thereupon duly filed a petition for betterments and offered evidence tending to show that he had expended a substantial sum of money in making permanent improvements.

Upon the foregoing facts the following question of law arises:

Can the defendant maintain his petition for betterments ?

The sale of the land under the original deed of trust, dated August, 1919, the purchase thereof by the plaintiff, and the deed from the trustee to the plaintiff dated 28 September, 1926, terminated the relationship

*17

of mortgagor and mortgagee between the plaintiff and the original owners and mortgagors of the land. Hence, when the defendant went into possession in 1927 there was no such relationship existing between him and the plaintiff. Consequently, C. S., 710, does not apply.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.