Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York January 16, 1935 (Cohoes Bronze Co. v. Georgia Home Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-01-1935

McNamee, J.

The fire referred to in the complaint occurred October 7, 1930. The policy provided that no suit to recover a claim thereunder should be maintainable unless commenced within twelve months after the fire. On October 3, 1931, there was delivered to the sheriff, apparently for service on the defendant, a summons in the action. The sheriff failed to effect service; and on October 22, 1931, the summons was served on the defendant by a private person.

On the trial, for the purpose of showing the delivery of the summons to the sheriff with the intent that it should be served, the plaintiff offered to prove what was said to the sheriff at that time. The court excluded this proof, and the plaintiff excepted. The court also held that service of the summons “ must be by the sheriff,” and that the service made by the private person was invalid. To this ruling the plaintiff excepted. Thereupon the complaint was dismissed on the merits.

The statute (Civ. Frac. Act, § 17) provides that an attempt to commence an action in a court of record is equivalent to the commencement thereof, for the purpose of avoiding a statute of limitations, provided the summons is delivered to the sheriff “ with the intent that it shall be actually served.” And this section applies to the time limited by an insurance policy for the commencement of an action thereupon. (Hamilton v. Royal Insurance Company, 156 N. Y. 327.) By the language of the section it is quite as mandatory to prove the intent of the plaintiff that the summons shall be served, as it is to show its delivery to the sheriff. And the instructions, if any, imparted to the sheriff upon such delivery may be equally important; and a restatement of them in court is a proper way to show the intent of the plaintiff, and to characterize the act of delivery. These were essential parts of plaintiff’s case.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.