Ohio Court of Appeals June 24, 1935, No 1275 (Fink v. Miamisburg Hydraulic Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-06-1935
*515OPINION
By HORNBECK, J.
Upon the issues joined and the evidence, we are constrained to say that the plaintiffs have not sustained their case by that degree of proof which is enjoined upon them. We are not certain that they have not suffered some damage by reason of the erection of the dyke, but possibly because of the nature of the case and difficulty in securing proof the record does not support their contention to a degree which would enable us to find for them.
It seems fairly well established that the levee along plaintiffs’ farm was broken through in several places during the flood of 1913. The extent to which high water came upon and flowed over the Fink land from 1913 to 1926 is not specifically shown. It is only testified to in general terms. It is but a natural law that water if it comes on wiih any velocity whatever will wash out land upon which it flows and that each succeeding time it will cut in deeper. We cannot say in view of all the facts that the damage which has been done to the Fink land has not come about by reason of the breaks in their levees. The testimony of the plaintiffs touching the contour of the shore line and the land adjacent to the dam on the east side thereof prior to 1926 is but general. We are satisfied that there were times prior to 1926 when the water flowed with much force over and upon the land of the Hydraulic and Elter beyond the east side of the dam. This had the effect of temporarily widening the channel during high water and accommodated a great bulk of the flow. The result thereof was to lessen somewhat the velocity of the current to the northwest and to reduce the amount of water which went onto the Fink land.
If the defendant company had changed the shore line or if it had narrowed the channel of the river and thereby caused damage to the plaintiffs, clearly it would be liable It is upon this narrow question that this case, in the main, rests.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit