Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit April 22, 1935, No. 10177 (Bromley v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-04-1935
SANBORN, Circuit Judge.
Harvey Bromley, upon a trial before a jury, was convicted of a violation of section 267 of title 26 U. S. C. (26 USCA § 267), for having in his possession distilled spirits, the immediate containers of which did not have affixed thereto stamps denoting the quantity of distilled spirits contained therein and evidencing payment of all internal revenue taxes imposed on such spirits. From the judgment entered upon the jury’s verdict, he has appealed.
The errors assigned relate to the sufficiency of the evidence, the rulings upon the evidence, and the refusal of the court to give certain requested instructions.
It is necessary to determine whether, upon the record presented to us, any of the questions sought to be raised can be reviewed.
In authenticating the bill of exceptions, the trial judge certified as follows: “The above and foregoing are all of the exceptions taken and noted in the trial of this cause to the instructions given and the charge of the court to the jury, together with the instructions given in the charge of the court to the jury, and all instructions requested by the defendant and refused by the court, and the defendant’s exceptions thereto.”
While the bill itself contains recitals indicating that all of the evidence is included therein, the allowance and approval of the bill by the judge is limited, by his certificate, to the exceptions to his charge, the charge itself, and the requests for instructions, their refusal, and exceptions thereto. He has not certified to the evidence or to the rulings upon the evidence or the exceptions taken by the defendant to such rulings.
To review the question of the sufficiency of the evidence, this court must have before it a bill of exceptions, authenticated by the trial judge, which not only contains all of the evidence, but which shows in some way that it was allowed and approved by the judge as containing all of the evidence. Roberts v. National Savings Life Ins. Co. et al. (C. C. A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit