District Court, S.D. Florida January 23, 1935, No. 1583 (Table Supply Stores, Inc. v. Hawking)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-01-1935

AKERMAN, District Judge.

I have on three separate occasions decided that, if the National Industrial Recovery Act (48 Stat. 195) is to be construed so as to give the executive branch; *889of the government the right to regulate or control a purely intrastate business as contradistinguished from interstate commerce, then the National Industrial Recovery Act is without constitutional authority of Congress to enact such legislation, and is therefore null and void.1 This is the settled law •of the division of this district over which I preside until such decisions are reversed by one of the proper appellate courts.

The picture presented by the sworn bill, which, not being denied, is to be taken as true for the purpose of granting or refusing an interlocutory injunction, is enough to shock the sensibilities of a person trained in the belief that we are living under a constitutional government where the citizen is governed by laws and not by men. According to the bill, the complainant is a corporation engaged in a purely intrastate mercantile business, with branch stores in various cities throughout the Southern district of Florida, and one of the respondents, through a secret investigation, procured affidavits and forwarded the same to another respondent, whereupon the other respondent made a report to the Regional Compliance Board of the National Industrial Recovery Administration which holds its sessions in another state approximately five hundred miles away from the present office of the complainant; whereupon the complainant is cited to appear before the Regional Compliance Council at Atlanta, Ga., and, upon complainant’s representative appearing, the Regional Council refused to furnish complainant with a copy of the charges filed against it or the names of the witnesses .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.