Supreme Court of New Jersey September 11, 1935 (Pennsylvania Railroad v. Board of Public Utility Commissioners)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-09-1935

Per Curiam.

The board of public utility commissioners by its order dated September 20th, 1930, initiated a proceeding directed toward the elimination of the grade crossing of the Pennsylvania Railroad Company at Oak Tree road, Iselin, township of Woodbridge. The decision of the board was dated March 6th, 1934, and the order was issued on March 22d, 1934. The order directed the Pennsylvania Railroad Company to substitute for the grade crossing an underpass in accordance with plans perfected by the board and incorporated in the order. On October 18th, 1934, the railroad company applied for and obtained a rule to show cause why a writ of certiorari should not issue to review that order. This is the return of the rule.

The reasons, printed in the state of case, upon which prosecutor seeks the writ are six in number, but all revolve, as does the prosecutor’s brief, around two prepositions, namely, first, that the last testimony taken in the matter by the board was *767on June 29th, 1931, and that between that time and the date of the order conditions incident to the elimination of the crossing had materially changed, wherefore, as is said, there was no competent evidence upon which the order could be based, and, second, that the prosecutor is under financial stress.

We find no evidence of changed conditions. Prosecutor considers that the court should take judicial notice of an increase in the cost of materials and of labor during the period mentioned; but we think that if there were changes in construction costs and that these changes had material bearing upon the issue the matter should have been one of proof before us. Prosecutor states that it was not permitted, before the determination, to submit testimony addressed to the construction scheme incorporated in the order.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.