California Court of Appeal September 29, 1936, Civ. 5554 (Rodehaver v. Mankel)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-09-1936

THOMPSON, J.

The defendant has appealed from a judgment which was rendered against him in the sum of $2,066.63 for a balance due the plaintiff on an open book account. In a cross-complaint filed by the defendant, he claimed that plaintiff owed him $9,500 as a balance due on an open book account. In plaintiff’s answer to the cross-complaint he alleged that the judgment which was rendered in a former ease between the same parties was

res judicata

with respect to the 'defendant’s claim asserted in his cross-complaint. In the present action the court found that the defendant was indebted to plaintiff on an open book account in the sum of $2,066.63; that the judgment in the former action is

res judicata

and that defendant was entitled to recover nothing on his cross-complaint. Judgment was accordingly rendered in favor of the plaintiff for the sum of $2,066.63.

The appellant contends that the court erred in admitting in evidence, over his objection, the judgment roll in the former case upon the plea of

res judicata

for the reason that it appears the defendant’s claim asserted in his cross-complaint grew out of “an entirely different contract” from the one determined in the former ease; that the amount of the judgment in this case is excessive, and that the court erred in admitting evidence affecting an account with the Northwest Construction Company, a stranger to the transactions involved in this proceeding.

We are of the opinion the court did not err in admitting in evidence the judgment roll in the former cause. The court’s finding that the former judgment between the

*599

same parties is

res judicata

upon the claim asserted by the defendant in his cross-complaint in this suit appears to be adequately supported by the evidence.

An examination of the judgment roll of the former action discloses the fact that one J. C. North brought suit against this defendant, C.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.