Arizona Supreme Court September 28, 1936, Civil No. 3724. (Monaghan v. Barnes)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-09-1936
LOCKWOOD, C. J.
This is an action brought by Ruby C. Barnes, hereinafter called plaintiff, against Anna Lou Monag'han and Elizabeth Eckles, hereinafter called defendants, for a declaratory judgment as to the meaning of a written lease and option and to reform its terms. From the judgment rendered, this appeal was taken.
The uncontradicted facts and the issues of the case are as follows: On June 15, 1934, Anna Lou Monaghan and Elizabeth Eckles were mother and daughter, and were the tenants in common of certain real estate in the city of Phoenix, commonly called the Apache Hotel, each owning as her sole and separate property an undivided one-half interest therein. At the time the lease in question was executed, Mrs. Monaghan was in Phoenix operating the property as a hotel, while Mrs. Eckles was at her home in Glendale, California. Plaintiff, who was then the lessee of the San Carlos Hotel in Phoenix, was in Roches
*215
ter, Minnesota, the San Carlos property being managed by her husband, J. C. Barnes. Bussell Shedd, who was a real estate agent in Phoenix, had approached Mrs. Monaghan in regard to the selling or leasing of the Apache Hotel, and, finding that she was disposed to consider an offer thereon, he, together with Barnes, called on her and discussed the possibility of a lease and option to purchase. Several visits were made at which the matter was discussed, and finally it was agreed that a written contract should be prepared to be submitted to Mrs. Barnes, in Bochester, and Mrs. Eckles, in Glendale, before it was finally executed. Barnes thereupon suggested that an attorney by the name of C. T. McKinney be employed to prepare the proposed lease and option, which was agreed to by Mrs. Monaghan, and a lease was so prepared. A copy thereof was delivered to Mrs. Monaghan, and she spent a day or two examining it and analyzing its terms.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit