Supreme Court of Florida May 28, 1936 (Williams, Et Ux. v. Robineau)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-05-1936
Terrell, J.
S. P. Robineau as trustee filed his bill of complaint in Gilchrist County to foreclose a mortgage, C. H. Williams and Ruth Williams, his wife, J. M. Williams and Rosa L. Williams, his wife, Consolidated Naval Stores Company, and others, were named as parties defendant. C. H. and J. M. Williams, as partners under the firm name of Williams Brothers, filed their answer and cross bill in which they resist the foreclosure by alleging their ownership of tax deeds covering a portion of the lands described in the mortgage. The cross bill prays for foreclosure of their tax deeds under Chapter 14572, Acts of 1929, Laws of Florida.
S. P. Robineau as trustee answered the cross bill in which he admitted the tax deeds and the priority of the
*424
liens created by them but resisted their foreclosure on the ground that the lien so created had been legally discharged and exhausted by rents and profits taken from the lands by Williams Brothers during a period of years they were worked and used by them (Williams Brothers) for turpentine and timber purposes.
After Robineau filed his answer to the cross bill Williams Brothers in due course moved to be permitted to amend the latter by striking that portion praying for foreclosure of it under Chapter 14572, Acts of 1929. This motion was denied, a receiver • was appointed, and an examiner was designated to take and report the testimony. Williams Brothers then renewed their motion to be permitted to amend their cross bill. This motion was denied and Williams Brothers prosecuted the instant appeal.
Did the Chancellor commit error in refusing to permit Williams Brothers to amend their answer and cross bill to Robineau’s bill to foreclose, is the sole question we are called on to answer.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit