Supreme Court of Iowa May 5, 1936, No. 43540. (Scott v. State Board of Assessment & Review)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-05-1936
Richards, J.
Chapter 82 of the Acts of the Extraordinary
*1061
Session of the Forty-fifth General Assembly of Iowa (Code 1935, section 6943-fl et seq.) purports to impose a personal net income tax, a business tax on corporations, and a retail sales tax. Plaintiff, an income tax payer within the purview of the act, brought this action in equity on his own behalf, and allegedly on behalf and for the benefit of all other personal net income tax payers, alleging that aforementioned chapter 82 was not legally enacted, and praying that defendants be enjoined from the assessment against or collection from plaintiff and all others of the personal net income tax imposed in said chapter. Defendants are the officials of the state on whom the act conferred the powers of its administration, .including the collection of the taxes.
Pertinent to plaintiff’s claim that above-mentioned chapter 82 was not legally enacted, we first outline the facts as shown in the record. This act originated as a bill introduced in the House of Representatives on November 9, 1933, designated as House File No. 1. Subsequently it was read a first and second time, and amended in certain particulars. On January 25, 1934, the bill was read a third time and immediately placed upon its final passage, and upon a yea and nay vote the bill as amended was passed by the House by a constitutional majority, the ayes and nays being entered on the journal. On the last-mentioned date the bill reached the Senate, where on later days it was read a first and second time. Amendments were proposed and adopted. On February 7, the bill was read a third time, placed immediately upon its final passage, and upon a yea and nay vote passed the Senate by a constitutional majority, the ayes and nays being entered on the journal. On February 8, the House refused to concur in the Senate amendments. On February 12, a joint conference committee of the two Houses was appointed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit