Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) March 10, 1936 (Kinder v. Commonwealth)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-03-1936

Opinion op the Court by

Stanley, Commissioner

Affirming.

Charlie Kinder appeals from a judgment of manslaughter with a penalty of twenty-one years in prison.

He and the deceased, Burt Gambrel, with Bill Jackson and Arthur Mayo, returned to Barbourville about 2 o ’clock in the afternoon after riding around for some time in Kinder’s automobile, a $65 Ford. Some,, if not all, of the party had been drinking. There is evidence that Kinder gave Gambrel the ignition key and permission to use the automobile, as he had frequently done before. Kinder, however, denies this. He and Mayo went to get something to eat and later found that his car was missing from the place he had parked it. He informed some of the police officers that his automobile had been stolen, and asked if they had seen it. He indicated with profanity his belief that. Gambrel had taken the machine, and said he would kill him if he caught him near the car.

Kinder went with Mayo and a young lady to Cor-bin looking for the machine and soon discovered it on Main street being driven by Gambrel, with Jackson by his side. Mayo blew his horn several times and, according to Kinder, forced the car to the curb where it stopped. However, it appears that Gambrel turned the corner of Sixth street and stopped close by, and that Mayo’s car was stopped on Main street near the corner. The proof of the commonwealth is that Kinder went across to his automobile with a pistol drawn and told Gambrel to “get his damned self out of there,” and

*147

then shot him through the open window of the door while Gambrel had both hands on the steering wheel and without his having said anything or made any demonstration. Kinder then went across the street to a filling station and asked where he could find an undertaker. One sitting there was pointed out, and he said to him: “I have got a fellow over there for you,” or “I shot a fellow over there.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.