Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) March 10, 1936 (City of Covington v. McKinney)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-03-1936

Opinion of the Court by

Judge Richardson

Affirming.

To recover damages to Ms residence, its contents, and the yard to his residence, of the city of Covington, caused by the city maintaining inadequate ditches on its premises and permitting the same to become stopped up, thereby causing the water of ordinary rainfall, flowing from its premises, to be accelerated and concentrated onto their premises, Claude and Anna McKinney brought this action. On a trial before a jury a verdict of $1,000 was returned in their favor on which a judgment was entered, and from which this appeal is prosecuted.

For their cause of action they set forth the metes and bounds of the lot on which their residence is situated and describe its location relative to the land of the city on which it maintains reservoirs for the purpose of furnishing the inhabitants of the city with water. They allege that the land on which the reservoirs are located lies in the rear of theirs and slopes toward it. The city had constructed and maintained walled ditches to collect and drain the surface water and sewage from its land; one, immediately in the rear of their residence; another,, on their premises, under the dwelling. The basis of their recovery is, the ditches were inadequate to carry the suriface water collected therein from the city’s premises and the city had permitted them to become stopped up, thereby causing an overflow of their premises, during ordinary rains. They confine their recovery to rainfall on certain dates during five years next before the commencement of the action. As a defense the city traversed the allegations of the petition as amended and alleged that the water which overflowed the McKinneys’ premises was caused by the .construction of the south side

*133

-of the Alexandria Turnpike immediately in front of the McKinneys’ property, where a fill in the roadway was made over and across a deep ravine, a natural drainage .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.