Supreme Court of Louisiana May 25, 1936, No. 33875. (Thomas v. Vega)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-05-1936

ODOM, Justice.

Plaintiff obtained judgment against Manuel M. Vega for $2,000 on May 22, 1934, in a suit on a promissory note. Prior to that date, but while the suit was pending, Manuel M. Vega, husband, made a dation en paiement to his wife conveying to her all of his property, both real and personal, for a recited consideration of $5,200, stated in the act to have been her separate and paraphernal funds received and made use of by him in his private affairs and business. In addition to this consideration, his wife, Mrs. Paule Marie Delery Vega, who joined her husband in the notarial act of transfer and accepted the same, unconditionally assumed, bound, and obligated herself “to pay and discharge, in lieu, place and stead of and at the complete release and discharge of her said husband, the following described mortgages, debts and obligations of the same Manuel Vega.”

The mortgages assumed operated against the real estate conveyed, the balance due amounting to approximately $6,050. It seems to be conceded that the value of the property transferred was about equal to the debt stated .to be due the wife and the amount of the debts assumed by her.

Plaintiff, the judgment creditor of the husband, brought this suit to set aside the dation en paiement, alleging that it was null, void, and of no effect for the following reasons : First, that a wife cannot bind herself for the debts of her husband, or of the community; second, that the giving of movables as part of a dation en paiement is prohibited by law; and, third, that the recitals of fact by the husband in the act are untrue.

The defendant in answer specifically denied the allegations made by plaintiff and alleged that he had received from his wife and used in connection with his own private business and affairs more than $5,200, which amount was her separate and paraphernal funds. There was judgment in favor of plaintiff, setting aside the dation en paiement, and the defendants appealed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.