Michigan Supreme Court March 2, 1936, Docket No. 50, Calendar No. 38,611. (Balyeat v. American Nat. Ins. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-03-1936

Fead, J.

In action on a life insurance policy, defendant had judgment on summary motion, the pleadings disclosing no issue of fact.

November 11, 1925, defendant issued its policy for $1,000 to Adolph O. Ewald, in which plaintiff was named as beneficiary. The insured paid premiums in cash to February 11, 1930. Thereafter, in accordance with request of the insured in his application, defendant charged premiums as loans against the policy until June 13, 1933, when the cash value became exhausted. Insured died November 23, 1933.

The “premium loan” clause of the policy provided for the charge of premiums as loans when requested by insured and—“if the premium is so charged, this policy will be continued in force the same in all respects as though the premium paid by said loan had been paid in cash, ’ ’ etc.

The policy also provided “guaranteed surrender options,” after three years’ premiums had been paid, by way of surrender of the policy and the insured taking (a) the cash value, equal to the loan value, (b) paid-up insurance, or (c) extended term insurance for the face amount of the policy, as set out in tables. It also provided “automatic non-forfeiture benefit,” upon which plaintiff bases her case, and which reads:

“If this policy is not continued in'force by the payment of premiums either in cash or by the opera

*696

tion of the premium loan provisions herein, and if the insured prior to the expiration of the grace period has not requested one of the options as provided above, the company, at the expiration of said grace period corresponding to any unpaid premium, without action on the part of the insured but under the same conditions which would otherwise entitle the insured to one of the options above set forth, will continue the insurance as extended term insurance as per option No. 3 above for such amounts as would have been in force had the payment of premium been continued.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.