Michigan Supreme Court January 6, 1936, Docket No. 99, Calendar No. 38,621. (Perry Mount Park Cemetery Ass'n v. Netzel)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-01-1936

Wiest, J.

Defendant purchased unrestricted property in the city of Pontiac, across the highway from plaintiff’s cemetery, and established thereon the business of wrecking automobiles and salvaging parts thereof.

Plaintiff filed the bill herein to restrain operation of such business, its accompanying noise, smoke from burning rubbish and unsightly accumulations, and the court, by decree, permanently enjoined defendant “from conducting the business of used auto car parts” and “the commission of any acts on said premises in any way related to the business of used auto car parts, including the selling, dismantling, or storing of used or wrecked automobiles.”

Review is prosecuted by defendant.

The decree goes too far. It strikes down defendant’s business. It should regulate and not destroy. Offensive use of defendant’s premises can be prevented by reasonable requirements, deadening noises and eliminating smoke and disagreeable fumes from burning waste material during hours when persons usually visit the cemetery. Noise at night will not disturb the absent, nor will smoke or fumes occasion the silent sleepers any discomfort.

Defendant’s plant may be unsightly and detract somewhat from the beauty of view from the cemetery, but mere esthetics is beyond the power of the court to regulate, especially in a case like this where both parties are in business for profit. A cemetery is not the most desirable neighbor, neither is defendant’s wrecking plant, and, therefore, when the owner of one complains of the undesirableness of the other, such fact should be kept in mind.

*100

Counsel for plaintiff had the applicable rule in mind in stating- to the court before introduction of proofs:

“We will be perfectly frank to tell the court if this place were covered up or something of that kind, we could have no legal objection to it. We are asking for injunctive relief and this being a court of equity, the court has a right to fit its decree to the facts shown.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.