Supreme Court of New Hampshire December 1, 1936 (Barnard v. Old Colony Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-12-1936

Woodbury, J.

This case comes before us upon demurrer to the plaintiff’s amended declaration. All facts well pleaded are therefore admitted

(Williams

v.

Mathewson,

73 N. H. 242), and for the purpose of overruling the demurrer it is only necessary for us to point out from those facts possible conclusions favorable to the plaintiff which might be reached by the trial court. Final interpretation of the policy “must of necessity depend upon a consideration 'of all the evidentiary facts and circumstances ’ bearing thereon.” Until consideration of such facts neither that court nor this is bound to adopt the construction suggested herein. If justified by the evidence a different conclusion may be reached.

Kann

v.

Company,

85 N. H. 41, 48. This result follows because “the construction of a written contract presents a question of intention, which is a question of fact.”

Kendall

v.

Green,

67 N. H. 557, 561. See also

Borchers

v.

Taylor,

83 N. H. 564, 567, and cases cited;

Saloshin

v.

Houle,

85 N. H. 126.

The endorsement of January 13,1933, gives coverage for theft, but only for the theft of property belonging to the corporations therein specified. It cannot be construed to extend such coverage to shippers generally because to do so would be to ignore the plain meaning of specific language limiting the application of the endorsement to those companies.

The case does not indicate who was the owner of the goods which were stolen. If they belonged to E. I. du Pont de Nemours & Co., or to any of its subsidiary or affiliated companies, then the defendant is liable. If, on the other hand, they belonged to someone else, and from the tenor of the briefs and arguments we understand that such was in fact the case, then the defendant’s liability depends upon the construction to be given to the endorsement of June 29, 1933. The wording of this endorsement leaves much to be desired in the way

*294

of clarity.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.