New York Court of Appeals May 26, 1936 (People v. Creighton)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-05-1936

Crane, Ch. J.

The defendants Frances Q. Creighton and Everett C. Appelgate were indicted and convicted for murder in the first degree for having killed Ada Appel-gate, the wife of the defendant Appelgate, on the 27th day of September, 1935, at 12 Bryant place, Baldwin, in the county of Nassau. The death was caused by arsenic poisoning. Before stating, the occurrences on the fatal day it may be well to see who these people are and under what conditions they had been living.

Frances Q. Creighton and her husband John Creighton had been living for some time in a one-story and attic bungalow at 12 Bryant place, Baldwin, Long Island. The bungalow' consisted on the ground floor of a living room, dining room, kitchen, two bedrooms and bath. At the front door was an inclosed porch. A stairway in the rear led to an open attic, the front part of which had been fitted up for a bedroom.

This couple were about thirty-six years of age and had two children, a daughter Ruth, fifteen years of age, a pupil in the high school, and a son twelve years of age.

*266

John and his wife had been married seventeen years. He was employed in the county engineer’s office at a salary of $166 a month. In 1928 he had become acquainted with Appelgate through membership in the American Legion. They were both members of a post in Nassau county and frequently attended its meetings and social affairs together.

Appelgate was also thirty-six years of age and had married Ada Appelgate in July, 1920. He had entered the United States service during the war on October 2, 1918. The armistice was declared the next month. He became a very enthusiastic member of the Legion and during the summer of 1935 ran for county commander of Nassau county. He was defeated. At the times here in question he was employed as investigator in the Veterans’ Relief Bureau, making between twenty-five and forty dollars a week. He had a Chevrolet car which he drove around quite extensively.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.