New York Court of Appeals July 8, 1936 (People v. Marino)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-07-1936

lead-opinion

Crane, Ch. J.

Section 1308 of the Penal Law relates not only to the receiving of property, knowing it to be stolen, but also to the concealing and the withholding of any such property with like knowledge. Nowhere in this section is there a requirement that the thief must be specified, named or even known. The fact that a party has property which he knows to have been stolen, or receives it knowing it to have been stolen, is a crime, although he may never know who is the thief or from whom the property was stolen.

(People

v.

Wilson,

151 N. Y. 403.)

The difficulty in this case seems to have been in reading our previous decisions, such as

People

v.

Doty

(175 N. Y. 164, 168), as though the particular facts of that case had crystallized into a rule of law so that there could never be any dissimilar facts creating the crime. We must always read the decisions with a view of finding the principle which they are trying to enunciate. The rule which this court was trying to express is that other similar transactions are competent evidence to prove the crime of receiving stolen goods, provided there be

“

such a connection of circumstances as that a natural inference may be drawn that if the prisoner knew one article was stolen he would also be chargeable with knowledge 'that another was.” What these circumstances are which lead to this inference can never be known until they happen.

*319

The exact wording of section 1308 of the Penal Law is: “A person who buys or receives any property knowing the same to have been stolen * * * or who conceals, withholds, or aids in concealing or withholding any property, knowing the same to have been stolen, * * * is guilty of a felony * * *.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.