New York Court of Appeals December 31, 1936 (In Re the Accounting of Schorer)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-12-1936

Hubbs, J.

John B. Schorer died January 25, 1927. Letters testamentary under his will were issued to the appellant on February 7, 1927. On or about June 20th, 1927, the claimant, George E. Pfabler, filed a verified claim for medical services amounting to $2,500. The claim was filed by respondent’s attorneys together with a notice of

*249

retainer. The attorney who served those papers testified to a conversation with the attorney for the appellant in which the attorney for the appellant said:

“

Let it go along, and we’ll see what we can do; and when we come to render an accounting, we’ll see what we can do with it; and if we can’t do anything, we will go into court and thrash it out.” A

Thereafter, and until June 28, 1934, when respondent instituted this proceeding for a compulsory judicial settlement of the accounts of the appellant as executrix, no accounting was had and no action was taken with respect to the claim.

In the accounting proceeding the appellant answered and pleaded the six-year Statute of Limitations as a bar. The Surrogate decided that the six-year Statute. of Limitations did not apply and ordered a judicial settlement and a trial for determination of the claim. The Appellate Division affirmed, one justice dissenting.

The question on this appeal is whether the six-year Statute of Limitations, section 48 of the Civil Practice Act, applicable to contract actions, applied to the rejected claim against the estate then in process of liquidation in Surrogate’s Court. Section 211 of the Surrogate’s Court Act reads as follows:

“ § 211. Rejected claim to be tried on judicial settlement; limitation of action by creditor. If the executor or administrator doubts the justice or validity of any claim presented to him, he shall serve a notice in writing upon the claimant that he rejects said claim, or some part of it, which he specifies.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.