Supreme Court of North Carolina December 16, 1936 (Rosenbloom v. . Sinkoe)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-12-1936

ScheNCK, J.

The plaintiff introduced evidence from which the jury might have found that the defendant agreed to store and to sell the machinery at not less than the prices marked on the individual articles, aggregating $945.00, for a commission of 10 per cent, and further, that the defendant agreed to store the bench and tools. The defendant, on the contrary, introduced evidence from which the jury might have found that no such agreement was made, and that the machinery and the bench and tools were left with the defendant by the plaintiff as security for loans made to the plaintiff by the defendant, with the understanding that if said loans were not paid within a reasonable time the property should be sold and proceeds applied on said loans, and that after two years or more the property was so sold and the proceeds of the sale so applied.

The jury, after hearing the evidence, answered the issues in favor of the plaintiff, as hereinbefore set forth.

The exceptions principally urged on appeal are those which assail the charge of the court upon the third issue relative to the measure of damage. His honor held and charged the jury to the effect that if they answered the first and second issues in favor of the plaintiff their answer to the third issue would be the price at which the defendant agreed to sell the machinery. The only evidence relating to the price at which the defendant agreed to sell the machinery was that of the plaintiff, since the defendant denied the existence of any such agreement. The jury answered the issue in accord with the contention of the plaintiff, namely, $945.00.

It is the contention of the defendant that the measure of damage was the market value of the machinery, and not the price at which the defendant agreed to sell it, in the event that the jury found he agreed to sell it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.