Ohio Supreme Court June 24, 1936, 25723 (Squire v. Branciforti)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-06-1936

Stephenson, J.

There is really just one question here, namely, do the facts pleaded by the Brancifortis in their petition establish a trust relationship between them and the Union Trust Company? If they do, then the Brancifortis are entitled to a preference and the answer does not state a defense. If they do not, there being nothing to indicate a bailment, then Brancifortis

*352

have failed on their petition, as the relation of debtor and creditor would necessarily exist between the bank and Brancifortis, and they would stand in the shoes of a general creditor.

We say there is no bailment here, as the specie was destroyed, if there ever was a specie, when the Brancifortis withdrew their account by the withdrawal slip process and returned it to the bank, which credited it to an account known as the Escrow Deposit Account. If this was a trust fund deposited for distribution, the case comes within the purview of

McDonald, Admr.,

v.

Fulton, Supt. of Banks,

125 Ohio

St., 507,

182 N. E., 504, 83 A. L. R., 1107, and

Fulton, Supt. of Banks,

v.

University of Dayton,

129 Ohio St., 90, 193 N. E., 758, and the Brancifortis would be general creditors of the bank without claim for preference.

The third paragraph of the syllabus in the case of

Fulton, Supt.,

v.

University of Dayton, supra,

disposes of the proposition that money placed in a bank must be followed in specie or at least traced to a particular fund before a corpus can be provided for the trust, and we are not disposed to stray from the law therein announced, in this particular case.

We likewise adhere to the fourth paragraph of the syllabus in that case, to the effect that where trust funds were deposited in a bank pending distribution or investment, without an express agreement to the contrary, as to such moneys, the relation of creditor and debtor existed. But do we have such case here?

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.