Ohio Supreme Court February 26, 1936, 25553 (Squire, Supt. v. Tobin, Exrx)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-02-1936

Jones, J.

The trial court allowed the claim of the executrix as a valid general claim, but denied its preference over general creditors. The appellate court decreed that the claim be allowed as a preferred claim. Conceding that there was a divergence of judicial authority upon the legal question involved, the Court

*441

of Appeals rested its decision upon decisions of the Missouri courts, and notably upon the case of

Johnson

v.

Farmers Bank of Clarksdale,

223 Mo. App., 513, 11 S. W. (2d), 1090.

The Ohio appellate court held that when the bank, on June 14, 1931, denied withdrawal of the executrix’s-balance, concededly due, the relation of debtor and creditor terminated

eo instanti,

the bank then becoming a trustee for the amount due. Because it was impossible for the executrix to procure a judgment in the short time intervening between June 14, 1931, and June 17,1931, the Court of Appeals applied the maxim that equity regards as done that which should have been done, and based its decree accordingly. We fail to see how that equitable principle applies here. The relation of debtor and creditor continued to subsist. While the voluntary relation of debtor and creditor depositor may have terminated as between the bank and its depositor, nevertheless a new relation of debtor and creditor arose and continued to subsist as a claim or chose in action against the bank; but, even so, the procurement of a judgment thereon would not have impressed the bank funds with either lien or trust unless later followed by legal process and sequestration. The transaction involved was not a special deposit, nor was there a sequestration of any specific or identifiable

res

in the bank assets which would give one general creditor priority over other general creditors.

Richards

v.

Fulton,

75 F. (2d), 853. Under the conceded facts, the executrix at all times was a creditor of the bank and, like other creditors, was entitled to participate in the distribution of its assets.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.