Supreme Court of Oklahoma May 19, 1936, No. 26369. (Batchelder v. Knecttle)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-05-1936

PER CURIAM.

In this cause defendant in error, being plaintiff below, invoked the authority of the trial court, sitting in equity, to vacate and set aside an alleged incompetent’s death-bed deed, asking like relief against a bill of sale to certain personal [property executed by the same grantor under similar circumstances.

John M. Hughes, an aged paralytic, resident of Noble county, died on March 13, 1933, a victim of his advanced years and a progressive paralysis which antedated his death by several years. During the entire period of his disability he required constant icare and assistance in the simple functions of his living routine. Upon March 1, 1933, his malady struck him finally and fatally to his bed. From this date until his death his entire left side was useless; his right hand and arm were so palsied that he could not hold a pen with the one nor guide it with the other; and his speech was so impaired that he could but mutter “yes” or “no”, and frequently both, with apparent equivalence. On March 2, 1933, he lapsed into a coma from which he never rallied.

During his failing years he was cared for by his sister, Anna ¡Batchelder, defendant below, and plaintiff in error. At his death he was survived by two sisters, who are the (parties to this proceeding, and by several neices and nephews who are the children of brothers and sisters who preceded him in death.

Several years prior to his death John M. Hughes executed a will under the terms of which he divided his property equally between his two living sisters, the parties here, naming Anna Batchelder, plaintiff in error, as executrix. This will was properly proposed to the county court of Noble county, and, in due course, admitted to probate. The administration upon the estate was still incomplete at the date of the decree complained of by this appeal.

Upon' the morning of March 1, 1933, a nurse was summoned to attend the testator, now deceased. She found him in a state of collapse, obviously in extremis.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.