Supreme Court of Pennsylvania January 8, 1936, Appeal, 347 (Mayer v. Chelten Avenue Building Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-01-1936
Opinion by
Mr. Chief Justice Kephart,
A landlord seized his tenant’s goods in execution for defaulted rental payments of an apartment. The tenant secured a writ of replevin and, on the filing of a .bond, the goods were released from the lien of the execution but the sheriff permitted them to remain on the premises. After the writ was returned, the goods were re
*195
moved by a deputy sheriff to a public warehouse. The tenant then brought an action against the landlord charging that this removal was an unlawful eviction and in violation of her right to have the personal property remain on the premises.
When the tenant’s case was on trial, unable to prove any title or right to remain in possession of the premises or one that would enable her to keep her goods on the place, she was forced to try her action as one of forcible entry and detainer. To sustain such action there must be evidence of a breach of peace with a strong hand, coupled with dispossession from the premises and the exercise of an unlawful detention by menace, force, threats or fraud:
Com. v. Brown,
138 Pa. 447, 452. Of this there was no proof and appellant now attempts to argue that the evidence shows an unlawful eviction and conversion. But the record shows the case was tried and disposed of as one of forcible entry and detainer. The court below stated during the trial that it was receiving evidence to support such an action. Appellant’s counsel acquiesced in this. The opinion of the court below states explicitly that both counsel agreed that the pleadings were to be considered as an action for forcible entry and detainer. This agreement is not denied. When a case has been submitted, tried and decided on a given theory, this court on appeal will not review the record on a different theory:
Levy’s Est.,
307 Pa. 522;
Weiskircher v. Connelly,
256 Pa. 387;
Richardson v. Flower,
248 Pa. 35.
Appellant claims she had a right to the leased premises.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit