Superior Court of Pennsylvania March 2, 1936, Appeal, 16 (Calvey Motor Co. v. Coyer)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-03-1936

Opinion by

Rhodes, J.,

This case and the case of Calvey v. Coyer, 121 Pa. Superior Ct. 504, 184 A. 279, were tried together. In this case the plaintiff company, an auto sales agency, brought an action of assumpsit against the defendant, who was formerly president of the plaintiff company and one of its principal stockholders, to recover for cer

*511

tain merchandise alleged to have been sold to the defendant, and for certain services alleged to have been rendered to him individually. The jury before which the case was tried returned a verdict for the full amount of the plaintiff’s claim. Defendant’s motion for a new trial was refused. Defendant appeals from the judgment entered on the verdict.

Appellant first contends that the court below should have granted a new trial, because the verdict was against the weight of the evidence. We have carefully read and examined the evidence, • which, although conflicting, is sufficient to support the jury’s verdict. Plaintiff produced testimony that the appellant, while president of plaintiff company, ordered through it from the Supplee Biddle Hardware Co. $194.79 worth of table silverware, and authorized that the same be charged to him on the books of the plaintiff company; that the plaintiff serviced the appellant’s car to the extent of a charge of $7.65, on February 8, 1927, which service was rendered after the appellant had ceased to be active as president of the plaintiff company, although he did not formally resign until February 5,1927; that certain other services were rendered and articles sold by the plaintiff to the appellant, the evidence as to these services rendered and articles sold being conceded by the appellant to be sufficient to sustain the verdict as to such items.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.