Supreme Court of Rhode Island April 17, 1936 (Agras v. State Board of Public Roads)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-04-1936

Baker, J.

This is a petition filed under the provisions of general laws 1923, chapter 97, as amended by public laws 1929, chapter 1306, to recover damages allegedly caused the petitioner by reason of the condemnation by the respondent of certain property in the town of Westerly for highway purposes. A trial was had in the superior court before a jury which awarded the petitioner $1,200. A motion for a new trial was thereupon filed by the petitioner on the ground that the verdict was against the evidence in that the damages assessed were inadequate. This .motion was denied by the trial justice, and the case is now before us on the petitioner’s exception to this decision.

The testimony disclosed that the respondent condemned a certain building on Main street in Westerly in order to widen a highway. The petitioner held á lease on a part of the ground floor of this building where he conducted a restaurant consisting of a dining room and connecting kitchen. These premises had been occupied as a restaurant by different persons over a period of years. The petitioner’s first lease, bearing date of October 16, 1924, expired on

*164

October 31, 1929. He then obtained a second lease terminating October 31, 1934, under which he was required to pay an annual rent of $1,800. There was no renewal clause in this lease. The date of the condemnation was January 28,1932, and therefore at that time the lease involved herein had approximately thirty-three months to run. The sole quéstion in issue was the value of this leasehold interest to the petitioner at the time the condemnation took place.

At the trial, he introduced evidence tending to prove that the value of certain permanent improvements he had made in the restaurant in 1924, when he first went into occupation seven years prior to the condemnation in question, was about $2,000. In general these improvements consisted of a new front, panelling on a portion of the side walls, a tile floor, piping, and electric fixtures.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.