Court of Appeals of Texas May 11, 1936, No. 4597. (Hilker v. Agricultural Bond & Credit Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-05-1936
*545
MARTIN, Justice.
Appellee sued, and recovered judgment against appellant for the conversion of 1,820 bushels of wheat. Appellee held a chattel mortgage on the wheat crop of S. H. McCathern, near Grady, N. Mex., to secure it in the payment of a note for $1,057.73. Appellee alleged in part: “That thereafter said S. H. McCathern grew and harvested on said 300 acres of land situated on the Ed Leach farm a crop of wheat, and delivered to the said defendant herein 1820 bushels of said wheat which was grown and harvested on said lands upon which this plaintiff had and held said chattel mortgage lien, and said defendant, C. G. Hillcer, then and there received said wheat with full knowledge of the chattel mortgage lien held by this plaintiff, and without the knowledge or consent of this plaintiff converted to his own use and benefit all of said wheat.”
Appellee’s pleadings showed it to be a foreign corporation. Appellant contends that it should have pleaded and proven that it had a permit to do business in Texas. Appellee’s contract with McCath-ern and the alleged conversion was in New Mexico, not Texas. Plainly it did not have to have such permit to merely sue upon a cause of action arising in another state. Bringing such a suit is not “transacting * * * business” in Texas, under article 1529, R.S. 1925. If it had alleged it had a permit, or made allegations showing a necessity therefor, a different question would be presented. Smith v. Jasper County Lbr. Co., 124 Tex. 156, 76 S.W. (2d) 505. It did neither, and such matter had to be defensively pleaded in order to be raised. Oklahoma Tool & Supply Co. v. Daniels et al. (Tex.Com.App.) 290 S.W. 727. Appellant raised such question by a plea in abatement, but his allegations are not sustained by the evidence.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit