Court of Appeals of Texas January 22, 1936, No. 9700. (Texas Indemnity Co. v. McNew)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-01-1936

MURRAY, Justice.

Appellee, Joe McNew, instituted this suit against Texas Indemnity Insurance Company, seeking to recover, under the provisions of the Workmen’s Compensation Insurance Act (Vernon’s Ann.Civ.St. art. 8306, et seq.), for disability arising from an injury which he alleges he received while working for the Atlantic Pipe Line Company.

The trial was to a jury, and, upon the jury’s answers to the issues submitted, judgment was entered below in McNew’s favor for a lump sum recovery of $4,713.27. From that judgment the insurance company has prosecuted this appeal.

Appellant’s first proposition is that it was entitled to have submitted to the jury an affirmative issue as to what percentage of appellee’s incapacity was due to a prior injury, where such defense was raised by the pleadings and evidence.

It is well to here state that this cause was submitted to the jury by eleven special issues. The jury found, by its respective answers, as follows:

No. 1. That appellee was an employee.

No. 2. That he received the injury.

No. 3. That the injury was accidental.

No. 4. That he received the injury in the usual course of his employment.

No. 5. That he suffered physical disability arising from the injury.

No. 6. That the injury directly contributed to the plaintiff’s physical disability.

No. 7. That the physical disability arising from said injury was total. '

No. 8. That such physical disability was permanent.

Nos. 9 and 9a. The amount of his daily wages.

No. 10. That his compensation should be paid in a lump sum.

No. 11. That his physical condition was not due solely to causes independent of and not connected with his employment.

Appellant requested three special issues, which were refused by the trial court, and one of these special issues seeks to have the jury answer what per cent, of appel-lee’s disability was due to' a prior injury.

We conclude that the evidence was insufficient to raise the issue of a prior injury contributing to appellee’s present disability.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.