West Virginia Supreme Court April 21, 1936, 8342 (State v. Tenney)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-04-1936
Woods, Judge:
The defendant, Glen Tenney, prosecutes this writ of error to a conviction predicated on an indictment charging that he did “unlawfully and feloniously own, operate and maintain a certain plant for the manufacture of distilled spirits, contrary to Chapter 4, [Article VI] Section 10, Acts of the Legislature of the State of West Virginia, 1935, said Act known as the Liquor Control Act.”
The errors relied upon for reversal are the insufficiency of the indictment, on demurrer; and the refusal of the trial court to set aside the verdict as contrary to the law and evidence.
The indictment is attacked (1) as indefinite; and (2) as not negativing lawful ownership, operation or maintenance, as provided elsewhere in the Act.
As indicated on its face, the indictment was drawn under Section 10, Article VI, Chapter 4, Acts 1935 (Liquor Control Act), which provides:
*344
“A person who unlawfully owns, operates, or maintains a plant for the manufacture of distilled spirits, or aids or abets in the operation or maintenance of such a plant shall be guilty of a felony, and upon conviction shall be fined not less than one hundred nor more than one thousand dollars or confined in the penitentiary not less than one nor more than five years.”
The statute is clear and specific in its definition. Unlawful ownership, etc., of a plant for the manufacture of distilled spirits, as therein defined, constitutes the gravamen of the offense. And while either the letter or the substance of the statute defining the offense must be followed, it is generally recognized as the better practice to follow the former.
State
v.
Riffe,
10 W. Va. 794. Our Court has repeatedly held that an indictment substantially following the language of the statute is ordinarily sufficient.
State
v.
Nazel,
109 W. Va. 617, 156 S. E. 45;
State
v.
Foster,
21 W. Va. 767;
State
v.
Schnelle,
24 W. Va. 767;
State
v.
Boggess,
36 W. Va. 713, 15 S. E. 423;
State
v.
Pennington,
41 W. Va. 599, 23 S. E. 918;
State
v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit