Texas Supreme Court December 9, 1936, No. 6975 (Stillman v. Hirsch)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-12-1936
Mr. Justice SHARP
delivered the opinion of the court.
This case involves important procedural questions with respect to statutes and rules relating to filing motions for new trial, including the action of the trial judge in giving, refusing, or qualifying instructions to the jury, and the filing of assignments of error, as may be considered prerequisite to appellate review by the courts.
The Honorable Court of Civil Appeals held: (1) That motions for new trial shall be filed in the trial court, and that such motions shall be in writing and specify each ground on which it is founded, and that no error not specified shall be considered (unless fundamental); and (2) that assignments of error to the giving or refusal of charges or special issues cannot be reviewed in the absence of exceptions thereto. 84 S. W. (2d) *362501.. Because of. the important questions involved, a writ of error was granted.
This cause involves the construction of many articles of the statutes, and particularly Articles 1844, 2188, 2209, 2210, 2232, and 2237, Vernon’s Annotated Texas Statutes, and Rules 24 and 25 for -the Courts of Civil Appeals, as amended January 24, 1912, and Rule 71a, adopted on the same date, and Rule 101a, amended June 25, 1913, for the District and County Courts. For the sake of convenience, we set out the pertinent parts of the above-described Articles and Rules:
Article 2232 in part reads: “New trials may be granted and judgments arrested or set aside on motion for good cause, on such terms as the court shall direct. Each such motion shall:
% ^ ^ iji %
“3. Specify .each ground on which it is founded, and no ground not specified shall be considered.”
Article 2209 reads: “Where a special verdict is rendered, or the conclusions of fact found by the judge are separately stated, the court shall render judgment thereon unless set aside or a new trial is granted.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit