Court of Appeals of Texas November 16, 1936, No. 4665 (Vaughan v. West)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-11-1936
HALL, Chief Justice.
The appellee, West, sued appellant in trespass to try title to recover lot 14, in block 23, of the Summit place addition to the city of Houston, situated on the south side of Buffalo bayou. The prayer is for writ of possession and the recovery of rents at the rate of $40 per month from December 1, 1934.
The appellant answered by general demurrer, general denial, plea of not guilty, and specially answered alleging that plaintiff, West, does not exist, or, if he does exist, in the alternative, that he is a “straw man,” used in name only by the Mortgage Bond Company of New York and J. C. Leonard Company, who are the real plaintiffs in the case, suing in the náme of Joseph A. West. He further alleges: “Without waiving any of his right to a general defense herein, this defendant alleges fraud and negligence as against the plaintiff as to any muniment or claim of title he may rely upon. If he has any the same was procured unlawfully, through negligence and fraud, and are void; that the reasonable rental value of the property is $25.00 per month; that he has made improvements in good faith to the value of $200.00.”
By cross-petition he alleges that Joseph A. West, whom plaintiff has never seen nor heard of before, has by some manner of sham or pretense asserted title and right of possession to the defendant’s property, and undertaken to put a cloud upon .his title; that West, in collusion with the Leonard Company & Mortgage Bond Company, who are not parties hereto, has fabricated what he considers to be some legal claim to the property, and through such 'fabricated claim has undertaken to cloud defendant’s title, and has brought this suit for such purpose, to defendant’s damage in the sum of $500.
The only issue submitted to the jury was: “What, from the greater weight and degree of the credible evidence, do you find to be the reasonable rental value of the property in question since December 1, 1934?” The jury answered: “$192.50.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit