City of New York Municipal Court March 6, 1936 (Owners & Tenants Electric Co. v. Tractenberg)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-03-1936
Lewis (David C.), J.
The defendant charges the plaintiff and also the landlord corporation with the illicit traffic in electricity. Here is a challenge that must be met now — not later. If the indictment is sustained, that ends this lawsuit.
The question before the court involves the much-discussed submetering business. This court does not essay any opinion on any economic, technical, industrial or practical phase of this practice. The problem is not what such considerations might warrant, but what the law allows.
Both the plaintiff in this action and the landlord in this case are domestic business corporations organized under article II of the Stock Corporation Law. The landlord corporation entered into a lease with the defendant containing the following covenant: “ If the demised premises be in a building where the landlord shall desire to supply electric current to the tenant for lighting purposes, the tenant agrees that the tenant will purchase from the landlord or any other company designated by the landlord all electric current that the tenant requires at the demised premises and will pay the landlord for the same, as the amount of consumption shall be indicated by the meter furnished. Therefore price shall be the same as that charged for similar consumption by the Public Service Corporation which maintain conduits nearest the premises. * * * Any amount as to which the tenant shall at any time be in default for in respect to the use of electric current * * * shall be deemed to be ‘ additional rent ’ for the demised premises.”
*679The plaintiff’s brief tells us that pursuant to this covenant the landlord contracted with the plaintiff “ to install meters and the necessary electrical fixtures in the premises and to read, repair and inspect the meters and bill the tenants for electricity consumed and to collect in its own name for such electricity.” (See plaintiff’s brief, No. 1, p. 2.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit