New York Surrogate's Court May 23, 1936 (In re the Estate of O'Connor)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-05-1936
Wingate, S.
The question presently propounded is as to whether a referee appointed by the surrogate “ to hear and determine all questions arising upon the settlement of said account, which the surrogate has power to determine, and to make a report thereon to this court,” is under obligation to make or pass upon specific findings of fact and conclusions of law. The respondent maintains the affirmative of this position and seeks a remission of the report of the referee, Edward J. Connolly, Esq., heretofore submitted herein, for this purpose.
*523The effect of a decision by a referee so appointed underlies the entire issue. This is inherent in the enactment authorizing the submission to him, which is contained in section 66 of the Surrogate’s Court Act, and, so far as presently pertinent, provides as follows: “ In a special proceeding other than one instituted for probate of a will, and subject to the right of trial by jury of any question of fact, the surrogate may, in his discretion, appoint a referee to take and report to the surrogate the evidence upon the facts, or upon a specific question of fact; to examine an account rendered; to hear and determine all questions, arising upon the settlement of such an account, which the surrogate has power to determine; and to make a report thereon, subject, however, to confirmation or modification by the surrogate.” (Italics not in original.)
The nature of the office performed by the referee is apparent from the foregoing italicized words. He is merely a lineal descendant of the master in chancery under the practice of the early nineteenth century, who was said to be the “ right arm of the court.” “ He is its intrument for collecting evidence and reporting conclusions for the use of the court. His main duty is to report facts derived from the evidence submitted to him, and if he draws legal conclusions from the facts, he performs a function more germane to the duties of the judge.” (Austin v. Ahearne, 61 N. Y. 6, 12.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit