New York Surrogate's Court May 6, 1936 (In re the Estate of Miller)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-05-1936

Hetherington, S.

Appellant is the widow of decedent, who died on September 30, 1932. In proceedings had to determine the fair market value of his estate, the schedules disclosed five bank accounts totaling approximately $29,000 standing in the joint names of decedent and his wife which were payable to either or the survivor. Appellant claimed a deduction of $16,120 from the gross, estate upon the ground that, of the moneys on deposit, *609in the form recited, such sum originally belonged to and represented moneys earned by her in gainful occupations pursued during her married life. After conducting an oral hearing, at which the appellant was the only witness, the appraiser disallowed her claim. The pro forma order entered on his report taxed the entire fund, and from such order this appeal has been taken.

Authority for deducting the claim here made, if established, can be found in section 249-r of the Tax Law and particularly subdivision 5 which provides in substance that, in the case of joint bank accounts payable to the survivor, there shall be excluded from the gross estate “ such part thereof as may be shown to have originally belonged to such other person and never to have been received or acquired by the latter from the decedent for less than an adequate and full consideration in money or money’s worth.” The burden of establishing that a part of the fund on deposit should be excluded from the gross estate by virtue of the exception stated in subdivision 5 is upon the appellant. If she cannot meet the obligation imposed upon her, the entire amount is taxable. (Matter of Dwyer, 149 Misc. 603.) To support the deduction claimed, appellant was bound to establish that the moneys in question originally belonged to her and formed a part of the funds on deposit in the joint accounts. The proof relied upon to establish these requirements consists of her statement made in Schedule “ B ” of the motion papers and her oral testimony given before the appraiser.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.