Pennsylvania Orphans' Court, Washington County April 1, 1936, no. 10 (Donaldson's Estate)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-04-1936
Crumrine, P. J.,
James P. Donaldson died on December 13,1892, leaving a will by the terms of which he gave his widow, Catherine Donaldson, a life estate in his property, and then provided:
“It is my further will that at the decease of my wife, Catherine before named, all my estate shall be settled up and equally divided share and share alike to each of my children or their surviving heirs”.
Catherine Donaldson, the widow, died on August 28, 1934. John W. Donaldson was a son of James Donaldson, and he died on May 16, 1930, leaving one child, Helen Riley, and a widow, Emma Donaldson. By his will, John W. Donaldson left his entire estate to his widow.
Helen Riley, the daughter, contends that the legacy to John W. Donaldson was contingent on his surviving his mother, which condition was not fulfilled, and that on the death of Catherine the interest vested in Helen Riley as the only “heir” of John W. Donaldson under the will of James Donaldson.
Emma Donaldson’s position is that an undivided interest in remainder vested in John W. Donaldson on the death of his father, which interest passed at his death, under his will, to his widow.
The very able brief submitted by counsel seems to assume that the one question involved is whether the legacy to John W. Donaldson, one of the children, is vested or contingent, and they have cited most of the important cases bearing on that subject.
I do not see that this question is vital or its discussion necessary, for this reason: Under the terms of the will, John W. Donaldson actually could take only in the event that he was living at the death of the life tenant; this, for the very apparent reason that up to that time the life tenant enjoyed the estate. John W. Donaldson’s actual possession, then, was a conditional one.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit