Pennylvania Municipal Court, Philadelphia County February 20, 1936, no. 5 (Richman v. Shprintz)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-02-1936

Bonniwell, J.,

The plaintiff, a minor, by his next friend, filed a bill in equity against the defendant to cancel a contract made between them on October 23, 1935, and to recover a check which the plaintiff delivered to the defendant under the contract.

The bill averred that the plaintiff was 19 years of age; that on October 23, 1935, he entered into a written contract with the defendant for the purchase of a grocery store from the defendant, for the sum of $1,650, plus the cost of the merchandise on hand at the time of settlement; that, pursuant to the terms of the contract, the plaintiff delivered to the defendant a check of one Samuel Glaskier, in the sum of $500, made payable to the order of the plaintiff and endorsed over to the defendant, as a deposit on the purchase price; that the plaintiff received nothing from the defendant in the way of property by virtue of the contract; that the plaintiff, on October 30, 1935, repudiated and canceled the contract and demanded'the return of the check; that the defendant refused to deliver it to him, and, on November 15, 1935, instituted suit against the maker. Averring further that the proceedings would involve a multiplicity of suits, and that he had no adequate remedy at law, the plaintiff prayed that the defendant be enjoined from transferring or negotiating the check and from proceeding to enforce its payment, and be required to redeliver it to him.

On November 21,1935, the court ordered a hearing on the bill to determine whether a preliminary injunction should issue. On the following day the defendant filed preliminary objections to the bill, raising the issue that the plaintiff had an adequate remedy at law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.