New Mexico Supreme Court June 30, 1936, No. 4039 (Winston v. Fitch)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-06-1936

HUDSPETH, Justice.

This, is an appeal from the allowance of the district court of. an' attorney’s fee of $3,661.64 against the estate of Frank H. Winston, deceased, for services rendered by James G. Fitch to Ella W. Winston, executrix of said estate.

Frank H. Winston, a resident of Sierra county, N. M., died November 10, 1929. He and Ella Winston were married in 1874 in Wisconsin and in the year 1885 he became a merchant in Sierra county, N. M., and continued his mercantile business at the village of Fairview until the date of his death. Between the years 1895 and 1910 the decedent received as gifts, testamentary and otherwise, sums aggregating $27,650. His will recites these facts and states in detail the properties in which these funds were invested — mainly cattle and ranch properties which were listed as separate property in his will.

James G. Fitch, hereinafter referred to as claimant, was employed by the executrix immediately after the death of her husband, who had advised her to retain him. He performed the usual services for the executrix in connection with the probating of the will arid the administration of the estate, and gave advice to the executrix and her assistant when called upon so to do.

The will was admitted to probate the 6th day of January, 1930, and in due course an inventory was filed by the executrix. The property of the estate was duly appraised. The testator’s share of the community property was left to the widow, who was named executrix of the will. Provision was also made for an annuity of $1,500 for her out of the separate property of the testator. Several bequests were made to charitable and religious institutions and the Red Cross and Salvation Army were made residuary legatees.

The executrix stated to claimant that the wishes of her husband were sacred, but she later became dissatisfied with the disposition made of the property by the will and the division of the property therein made into community and separate property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.