Ohio Court of Appeals October 26, 1936, No 15336 (Strauss v. Dwyer)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-10-1936
OPINION
By MONTGOMERY, J.
Judgment was obtained in the Common Pleas Court by the defendant in error for damages for the wrongful death of his decedent and from that judgment error was prosecuted to this court.
The decedent was an employee of a tenant in a building of the plaintiff in error. He died as a result of being precipitated down an elevator shaft. It is conceded *85that the elevators, six in number, were owned and controlled by the defendant below, now plaintiff in error. The elevator in controversy was designated number five. Prior to his death the decedent, operating the elevator, had brought down some empty boxes from an upper floor to the second floor where he was working, filling the boxes near the elevator.
It is urged that there was error in the proceedings of the lower court in the following particulars:
1. In failing to declare a mistrial.
2. In the rejection and admission of evidence.
3. In the charge to the jury.
4. In that the judgment was contrary to law and manifestly against the weight of the evidence.
It is urged further that the trial court should have directed a verdict and that the-court should now render final judgment for the plaintiff in error. Of these claims in the order designated:
1. Counsel for defendant in error was in fault in injecting into the case the question of liability insurance. Such conduct would justify a reversal, had the question been saved or had opposing counsel insisted upon his contention that the jury be dismissed. However, his conduct in our judgment constituted a waiver of this right and he cannot now complain of this error. See Eckert v Schmidt, 47 Oh Ap 61, (16 Abs 351).
2. We find no prejudicial error in the admission or exclusion of evidence. The city ordinances which were objectionable were withdrawn from the jury and in fact eliminated from the amended petition as it now appears.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit