Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit January 13, 1936, No. 7753 (Chalaire v. Franklin)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-01-1936

MATHEWS, Circuit Judge.

Appellant brought this action to recover of appellee the sum of 47,774.12 Shanghai taels claimed by appellant under a written contract. The action was commenced on February 21, 1934. Thereafter appellant filed an amended complaint, which appellee answered. Both parties then moved for judgment on the pleadings. The trial court granted appellee’s motion and rendered judgment dismissing the action. This appeal is from that judgment.

Appellee moves to affirm the judgmenc on the ground.that “there was failure of essential appellate procedure prior to filing transcript of record,” and on the further ground that there was no replication, no request for findings, and' no bill of exceptions. The motion does not indicate what the alleged “failure of essential appellate procedure” consisted of. We have not discovered any such failure. Appellée’s answer, as hereafter shown, contained no well-pleaded affirmative allegations requiring denial. There was, therefore, no need of a replication. American Trading Co. v. Steele (C.C.A.9) 274 F. 774, 780. Since the case was not tried, but was submitted to the court below on motions for judgment - on the pleadings, no findings were necessary, nor was there any necessity for a bill of exceptions. Nalle v. Oyster, 230 U.S. 165, 177, 33 S.Ct. 1043, 57 L.Ed. 1439; Mitsui v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Ins. Co. (C.C.A.9) 202 F. 26, 28; St. Paul, M. & M. Ry. Co. v. Drake (C.C.A.9) 72 F. 945, 947. The motion is denied.

The amended complaint alleges that appellant and appellee were attorneys at law duly admitted and qualified to practice in Shanghai, China, and from May 1, 1924, to January 1, 1928, were engaged in such practice as partners, under an agreement entitling appellant to 60 per cent, and appellee to 40 per cent, of the profits of the partnership business, and that on February 10, 1927, they entered into the following agreement:

“Shanghai, February 10, 1927.

“C. S. Franklin, Esq., Shanghai.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.