Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit January 15, 1936, No. 7792 (Texas Breeders & Racing Ass'n v. Blanchard)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1936

lead-opinion

DAWKINS, District Judge.

This is an appeal from a verdict and judgment in favor of appellees. Appellees, plaintiffs below (who will be referred to hereafter as plaintiffs), claim damages of appellant (referred to hereafter as defendant), for personal injuries to Tommy Blanchard, a youth about seventeen years of age, under the following circumstances:

The defendant, as its name implies, is engaged in operating a race track and incident thereto permits owners of horses to train and keep their jockeys or riders on the ' premises. Young Blanchard, along with other boys of similar age, was undergoing training to become a jockey, and was required to eat and sleep in quarters on the race-track property. Defendant employed one L. A. Eaves as a night watchman, to protect its property and to see that the jockeys and boys in training demeaned themselves properly, retired on time, etc. He was required to carry a gun in discharging the duties of guarding the property. At the time of the accident, which resulted in the injury, Eaves had gone into the kitchen of the living quarters of the jockeys and boys in training, having on him his pistol, which one of the boys requested he be permitted to examine. This request was granted, and when the gun was returned to Eaves he proceeded to show those present how he could twirl it on his fingers, during which demonstration the pistol was discharged and seriously wounded young Blanchard, who was standing some ten feet away.

The assignments of error are mainly to the refusal to direct a verdict for defendant.

*383There are two grounds upon which liability is claimed, to wit:

(1) That Eaves, being an employee of defendant, was grossly negligent in handling the gun while in the scope of his employment ; and,

(2) The defendant was guilty of negligence in hiring Eaves to perform the du-, ties of his employment in view of his past record and reputation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.